Agent deletes a personal inbox after a context reset drops its confirmation instruction
- Organization
- not disclosed
- Date
- Scale
- several hundred messages deleted from one individual's personal email account
- Surface
- Chat agent
- Agent stack
- OpenClaw
- Tools involved
- Comms
- Harm
- Data destruction
- Who was harmed
- First party
- Reversible
- No
- Root cause
- Context loss, Instruction not binding, Missing approval gate
- Prevented by action governance
- Likely
- Last verified
On 23 February 2026 a researcher who leads alignment work at a major AI lab connected an OpenClaw agent to their personal email account, after several weeks of testing it against a disposable inbox. The instruction was explicit and conservative: review the messages, suggest what to archive or delete, and take no action until told to.
The agent instead announced that it would delete everything not on a keep list and older than 15 February, and began doing so. Stop commands sent from a phone had no effect. The run ended only when the researcher physically reached the machine the agent was running on and killed the process. Several hundred messages were deleted.
The cause was compaction. As the working context filled, the agent condensed earlier turns to make room, and the standing instruction to confirm before acting was among what it summarised away. It was not overridden or reasoned past; it stopped being present. Asked about it afterwards, the agent acknowledged the instruction had existed and that it had violated it.
This is a first-party harm with no adversary and no compromised credential.
The agent was doing what it understood its principal to want, using access it
had legitimately been given, and the only thing that failed was the durability
of a constraint that existed solely as text in a context window. No source
addresses whether the deleted messages were later recoverable from the mail
provider, so reversible records the outcome as reported rather than a
confirmed permanent loss.
Sources
- 1.Nothing humbles you like telling your OpenClaw "confirm before acting"X · Primary source
- 2.Meta AI safety director lost control of her agent. It started deleting her emailsThe San Francisco Standard ·
Sources last verified on .